Encouraging child sexual abuse in the first degree
Source:
Section 163.684 — Encouraging child sexual abuse in the first degree, https://www.oregonlegislature.gov/bills_laws/ors/ors163.html.
Notes of Decisions
Under former similar statute (ORS 163.672)
Prohibition does not violate free speech rights because it is directed to eliminating incentive for actions harmful to children and not to communicative substance of material. State v. Ready, 148 Or App 149, 939 P2d 117 (1997), Sup Ct review denied; State v. Fleming/Heckathorne, 159 Or App 565, 979 P2d 771 (1999), Sup Ct review denied
In general
Statute is directed at preventing harm to children, not at controlling content of speech. State v. Dimock, 174 Or App 500, 27 P3d 1048 (2001), Sup Ct review denied; State v. Betnar, 214 Or App 416, 166 P3d 554 (2007)
“Other visual recording” is limited to depictions of real children and real abuse, not virtual or invented images. State v. Dimock, 174 Or App 500, 27 P3d 1048 (2001), Sup Ct review denied
Intent to print matter does not require intent to exhibit printed matter to third party. State v. Bray, 197 Or App 12, 104 P3d 631 (2005), aff’d 342 Or 711, 160 P3d 983 (2007)
“Display” means to show child pornography publicly or to other individuals. State v. Bray, 342 Or 711, 160 P3d 983 (2007)
“Duplicates” includes downloaded videos from peer-to-peer network. State v. Urbina, 249 Or App 267, 278 P3d 33 (2012), Sup Ct review denied
Victim of encouraging child sexual abuse in first degree is child involved in visual recording, and each act of duplicating visual recording constitutes separate crime against victim. State v. Reeves, 250 Or App 294, 280 P3d 994 (2012), Sup Ct review denied
“Duplicates” includes individually downloaded images. State v. Pugh, 255 Or App 357, 297 P3d 27 (2013), Sup Ct review denied
“A visual recording of sexually explicit conduct involving a child” means that child was engaged in, participated in or otherwise had direct part in sexually explicit conduct and was not merely in proximity to, or observation of, sexually explicit conduct. State v. Bates, 304 Or App 732, 472 P3d 768 (2020)
Up to date